We’re with quic. I’d rate them 14.76 out of 19.4.
They’re good, similar model to Bigpipe in that there’s no support team.
Previously with Voyager, they were good but quic was gigabit for the Voyager 300/100 price. Before that Bigpipe, also good.
Honestly, unless you have special requirements (static ip, etc.) just look for the best deal each year.
There’s a middle ground with your 3rd option, a Washworld or equivalent. They capture and reuse or discharge into wastewater instead of stormwater. You can clean how you normally would without the risk of scratching that may come from a regular car wash.
They frown upon this (technically against their posted T&C’s) but if you go early or late and take a bucket and cleaning equipment there’s not usually an attendant around to tell you off. I used to water blast and soak the car, squirt a bit of the soap in the bucket and hand wash, then rinse. Cost less than an automatic wash and got a better result.
This is no longer the case. Starting in October egress is free up to 3x the volume stored with them.