It’s really an entirely different animal than either of them, but ranks right up there with them in terms of quality.
SG1 is a 50/50 serious/fun ratio, with long running plot threads mixed in with adventure- of-the-week episodes. It’s a bunch of friends saving the galaxy and having fun doing it. It’s got a real sense of Earth’s slow progression from the mostly forgotten backwater homeworld of humanity all the way to being a major power in two galaxies.
B5 is like a 90% serious novel about war and politics.
BSG is 100% grim, and it becomes really obvious in later seasons that while the Cylons might’ve had a plan, the writers sure as shit didn’t know what it was supposed to be. This unfortunately makes it overall the weakest of the three IMHO.
I thought the Cylons’ plan was to eliminate humanity and replace it with a “better” version, which was the human cylons? It was interesting that their religion ended up getting in the way of that. But I didn’t hate BSG’s ending, which I realize puts me in the minority.
Anyway, thanks for sharing the detailed opinion, I appreciate it. I think I’ll give SG a shot later tonight. Other than the Expanse, high quality sci-fi has been hard to come by for a while now, so it’ll be cool to try something new.
How does this show compare to Babylon 5 or BSG?
It’s really an entirely different animal than either of them, but ranks right up there with them in terms of quality.
SG1 is a 50/50 serious/fun ratio, with long running plot threads mixed in with adventure- of-the-week episodes. It’s a bunch of friends saving the galaxy and having fun doing it. It’s got a real sense of Earth’s slow progression from the mostly forgotten backwater homeworld of humanity all the way to being a major power in two galaxies.
B5 is like a 90% serious novel about war and politics.
BSG is 100% grim, and it becomes really obvious in later seasons that while the Cylons might’ve had a plan, the writers sure as shit didn’t know what it was supposed to be. This unfortunately makes it overall the weakest of the three IMHO.
I thought the Cylons’ plan was to eliminate humanity and replace it with a “better” version, which was the human cylons? It was interesting that their religion ended up getting in the way of that. But I didn’t hate BSG’s ending, which I realize puts me in the minority.
Anyway, thanks for sharing the detailed opinion, I appreciate it. I think I’ll give SG a shot later tonight. Other than the Expanse, high quality sci-fi has been hard to come by for a while now, so it’ll be cool to try something new.
BSG is a lot lower than the other two.