You’re clearly upset because you THINK it won’t have an impact and you WISH they were doing something else. Which is weird because this protest doesn’t preclude them from doing anything?
Its not like I’m choosing to use a sick day today or next week to attend one protest or the other.
I’m sad I can’t get you to understand how businesses run or basic economics. Even if you pretend no businesses are running on fumes and that missing a payment doesn’t have an impact for anyone doesn’t make it true.
Or what about this brain blast: not all demand is the same. If I skip lunch today I won’t buy lunch twice tomorrow to make up for it… If everyone did that, all restaurants lose 3% of their monthly revenue automatically. Is that not an impact? Is there a magic percentage that it needs to meet to be “impactful”?
Did you ever consider what would happen if it wasn’t just you but everyone in the city was late on rent? You’re conflating an individual action’s impact with collective impact. Your landlord can price in some percentage of missed payments the same way that a store can price in shoplifting. Being drastically off on that estimate is still a problem.
Again, if you’re arguing the protest won’t be widespread enough that’s fine. You could even argue that small businesses will be unfairly targeted by this protest and I’m here for it. But ineffective is not the same as performative.
No, you didn’t. You gave a hypothesis and then justified with assumptions, providing absolutely nothing concrete to support them beyond “trust me bro”.
Brother: restaurant no get money, money no come next day.
That’s not making any assumption. This type of protest hasn’t been tried in America at scale, how can I possibly present data. Who knows what the impact will be, why don’t we find out before we lable it pointless?
Do you have any data showing that me standing in front of my city hall on Tuesday with a sign makes a difference? Because it’s been tried quite a few times since Occupy and nothing has improved. Or is that also operating off of “trust me bro”?
This is coming from a person who wants to do both. Is your argument that we should do nothing?
I want you to know that I am treating your concerns seriously and have been writing a response, but it is already 5000 characters long and I need to eat dinner, so I hope you will allow me the courtesy of replying in time without assuming that I am either conceding or disregarding your comment.
You’re clearly upset because you THINK it won’t have an impact and you WISH they were doing something else. Which is weird because this protest doesn’t preclude them from doing anything?
Its not like I’m choosing to use a sick day today or next week to attend one protest or the other.
I’m sad I can’t get you to understand how businesses run or basic economics. Even if you pretend no businesses are running on fumes and that missing a payment doesn’t have an impact for anyone doesn’t make it true.
Or what about this brain blast: not all demand is the same. If I skip lunch today I won’t buy lunch twice tomorrow to make up for it… If everyone did that, all restaurants lose 3% of their monthly revenue automatically. Is that not an impact? Is there a magic percentage that it needs to meet to be “impactful”?
Did you ever consider what would happen if it wasn’t just you but everyone in the city was late on rent? You’re conflating an individual action’s impact with collective impact. Your landlord can price in some percentage of missed payments the same way that a store can price in shoplifting. Being drastically off on that estimate is still a problem.
Again, if you’re arguing the protest won’t be widespread enough that’s fine. You could even argue that small businesses will be unfairly targeted by this protest and I’m here for it. But ineffective is not the same as performative.
I continue to wait for examples from comparable scenarios that support the claim being made.
I just gave one, please continue to ignore it 👌
No, you didn’t. You gave a hypothesis and then justified with assumptions, providing absolutely nothing concrete to support them beyond “trust me bro”.
Give me any kind of data to support the claim.
Brother: restaurant no get money, money no come next day.
That’s not making any assumption. This type of protest hasn’t been tried in America at scale, how can I possibly present data. Who knows what the impact will be, why don’t we find out before we lable it pointless?
Do you have any data showing that me standing in front of my city hall on Tuesday with a sign makes a difference? Because it’s been tried quite a few times since Occupy and nothing has improved. Or is that also operating off of “trust me bro”?
This is coming from a person who wants to do both. Is your argument that we should do nothing?
I want you to know that I am treating your concerns seriously and have been writing a response, but it is already 5000 characters long and I need to eat dinner, so I hope you will allow me the courtesy of replying in time without assuming that I am either conceding or disregarding your comment.
Save yourself the trouble, this isn’t going anywhere
deleted by creator