That’s a very narrow-minded way of thinking about the idea of a higher power… If something can be explained by science, it doesn’t need an explanation based on anything else. But there are plenty of questions that science can’t answer, not because it’s not equipped to answer them, but because they ask things which cannot be known for certain; philosophical questions about reality and the meaning we assign to it. Like what is the value of a life? And again, that’s not to say that I believe in a higher power; I just think it’s impossible to be certain one way or the other.
Those are questions of metaphysics, and you’re right they can’t be answered by science. But you have to ask yourself, if they can’t be answered by science, that is they can’t be measured or falsified, then what meaning do they really have? If you think of an unknowable, non-interventional god, their existence is the same to us as not existing, so it has no meaning. Same with any meanings of life, or questions about whether we live in a simulation perhaps, anything you can’t measure is just a story essentially, until you can measure it.
That’s a very narrow-minded way of thinking about the idea of a higher power… If something can be explained by science, it doesn’t need an explanation based on anything else. But there are plenty of questions that science can’t answer, not because it’s not equipped to answer them, but because they ask things which cannot be known for certain; philosophical questions about reality and the meaning we assign to it. Like what is the value of a life? And again, that’s not to say that I believe in a higher power; I just think it’s impossible to be certain one way or the other.
Those are questions of metaphysics, and you’re right they can’t be answered by science. But you have to ask yourself, if they can’t be answered by science, that is they can’t be measured or falsified, then what meaning do they really have? If you think of an unknowable, non-interventional god, their existence is the same to us as not existing, so it has no meaning. Same with any meanings of life, or questions about whether we live in a simulation perhaps, anything you can’t measure is just a story essentially, until you can measure it.